Tuesday, May 3, 2011

After Osama

     U.S. agents killed Osama bin Laden in Pakistan. The al-Qaeda leader was responsible for great suffering; I do not mourn his death. But I do not celebrate it, either. I am worried about my country's security now, more than ever. Dread lingers over me: Pakistan may have to pay the price for this.

    Crowds justifiably celebrated bin Laden's death in downtown Manhattan, where a decade ago al-Qaida terrorists massacred nearly 3,000 Americans. The statistic that many people do not know is that since the subsequent US invasion of Afghanistan, terrorists have killed nearly five times that number of people in Pakistan. Five times. Before 2002, suicide bombing was a word unknown to Pakistanis. Now, suicide attacks by Taliban/al-Qaeda, have slaughtered over 34,000 Pakistani civilians, policemen and army personnel. The annual number of Pakistani fatalities from terrorism has surged from less than 200 in 2003 to more than 3,000 in 2009. Every day, Pakistanis are targets for bombs, bullets, cannons, and drones. Bin Laden declared war on Pakistan, too.

    Despite all of that, CNN was having a field day yesterday (I didn't even bother watching FOX). Their target: Pakistan. The crux of every conversation was Pakistan's supposed support for al-Qaeda and the likes. All of this may make for great rhetoric but makes no sense when one asks why Pakistan would care about the group that has killed thousands of Pakistanis and destroyed all kinds of infrastructure and investment? We were the world's second fastest growing economy in 2005 (China was first). Now, our economy is in the dumps. Are we really going to bring this upon ourselves? And yes, Osama was found in Abbotabad, but who is to say he stayed in one location. For ten years? Please. We also know that this operation wouldn't have been possible without the support of Pakistani forces. We are not the perpetrator, we are the ally and the victim.

     Pakistan is not a country that accommodates and hides mass murderers. Pakistanis just want to be left alone and go back to the time when their lives were plain regular: tranquil. If Osama bin Laden's death means that America can begin to withdraw its forces from Pakistan and Afghanistan and that we can somehow rediscover peace, then one day Pakistanis are going to celebrate, too. But till the continued al-Qaeda/Taliban operations all around the world, mass murder of innocent civilians in my country and elsewhere, the norm of racial profiling of American-Muslims, human right injustices in Abu Ghraib and Guantanamo Bay and all such heinous acts are not put to end, I do not have a reason to celebrate.





8 comments:

  1. I am surprised no one has posted a comment to this yet. I was pointed here via Facebook by the way.
    I believe as you do that most Pakistanis want peace and most Pakistanis wanted Bin Laden gone, but it would be naive for me to believe that Bin Laden couldn't have bribed military officials to turn a blind eye to his presence in Pakistan. All in all, war sucks and war doesn't always discriminate between the innocent and the guilty .

    ReplyDelete
  2. Even before discussing if Pakistan is being termed as a hideout for terrorist, shouldn't we first get it clear that it was actually Usama bin laden who was killed in Abottabad. I mean, where have u seen any footage of him being evacuated from the place or even him shot dead at the place. the picture being circulated everywhere was in the state department website a year ago. So first get it confirmed that who the hell is being buried in the sea.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Anonymous: Valid point. But also let me say, this operation wouldn't have been a success had it not been for the cooperation of Pakistani military and intelligence - just as Obama rightly gave them credit in his speech. Another country does not operate on Pakistani soil without the knowledge and consent of Pakistan's forces.

    Usama: We can spend years and years on conspiracy theories and still never know the truth. You're not going to wake up one fine day and hear Obama go, "Sorry guys..Made a mistake. That man we killed, yeah, wasn't Bin Laden." What's important is what Pakistanis have to face now, at home and abroad.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Anonymous: Well it would be naive to say, "most Pakistanis want peace and most Pakistanis wanted Bin Laden gone" to a country that has lost more than 35000 civilians and military personnel, bombings in all its major metropolitan areas, and leaving the rest terrified. Therefore, not most but all Pakistanis wanted the murderer of peace in Pakistan dead.

    Are you talking about bribing the same military officials who have been cooperating with the US on "war on terror" and had captured more terrorists, mostly the top leadership, than anyone else including the USA?
    OR
    The military official responsible for the breach of security when a commercial airplane entered the No Fly Zone and hit the most sensitive US military installation, Pentagon?

    ReplyDelete
  5. Agreed...
    seriously are you telling me that we all expected a middle power country to capture the world's most wanted, dangerous and feared man ..when a world's super power with every technology possible cannot even control the illegal immigrants crossing borders everyday from Mexico for soo many years? Really?

    Why did it take US 10 whole years to finally find him when they already have every single modern technology available to them? Pakistan did not have all the technology that they could've used... Pakistan is being accused of "not doing enough" even tho Pakistan greatly contributed in capturing and killing the most wanted terrorist for past few years...

    It sounds absolutely ridiculous that Pak would have anything to do with it when our friends and families go out there everyday not knowing if they'll return to homes safely or be the victim of a terrorist attack..
    CNN seriously needs to stop all this BS!! Not one article on CNN talks about how Pakistan is now the number one target of al-qaida.. not one!!

    ReplyDelete
  6. Thanks for the great insight Ali and Sara. Also, worth noting is a link Sara shared with me:

    http://www.csmonitor.com/World/Asia-South-Central/2011/0503/Top-5-Al-Qaeda-linked-militants-Pakistan-has-captured/Umar-Patek

    ReplyDelete
  7. E-Man its a well balanced article. There is no doubt that we are the ally and victim in this war on terror and the role of Pakistan cannot be denied. My only question is How was the 'Most Wanted' guy able to live next to the West point of Pakistan with no questions asked? The size and structure of mansion itself should be enough to raise eyebrows.
    Secondly, why did our President Zardari allow the US Navy Seals to handle this operation when Pakistan's army is quite capable of getting this job done on their own! No one will consider us a Sovereign county if our actions contradict our statements. What's next, India running some errands in Islamabad while we sleep soundly in our cosy beds??

    ReplyDelete
  8. Well, Pakistan is up for more terrorism, and some terrorist group has announced to take revenge of Bin Laden's death too. Meanwhile, our very own Mr. Zardari is on an all paid trip to different countries, sponsored by the sleeping nation of Pakistan.

    ReplyDelete